SIGN ME UP FOR 30 DAYS OF FRESH COFFEE
CLICK HERE

By Marc Lawrence
Monday, Dec 8

The College Football Playoff’s final rankings were revealed on Sunday. To quote John Canzano of the Bald Faced Truth, “The talking heads on ESPN are busy twisting themselves into pretzels trying to justify an SEC-friendly bracket.” 

“The selection committee looks like a figure-skating judging panel. Notre Dame has to be steamed.”

The heavyhanded influence of ESPN? 

Oregon’s path to the national title? 

Alabama’s free pass? It’s a lot to digest.

Notre Dame isn’t just steamed. They are in utter disbelief and shock after being excluded from the 12-team College Football Playoff on Sunday. As a result, the Fighting Irish announced they have decided not to participate in a bowl game this season.

"As a team, we've decided to withdraw our name from consideration for a bowl game following the 2025 season," said a statement credited to the 2025 Notre Dame Football Team. "We appreciate all the support from our families and fans, and we're hoping to bring the 12th national title to South Bend in 2026."

Talk about picking up your marbles and going home — the Irish had been ranked in the top 10 of every CFP ranking release until Sunday, when they were placed No. 11 and were the first team out. Miami, which beat Notre Dame in Week One, moved ahead of the Irish in the final rankings to take the last at-large berth.

In the first CFP rankings released on Nov. 4, Notre Dame was No. 10 and Miami was No. 18. (See more below in ON TODAY’S CARD.)

Notre Dame AD Pete Bevacqua told ESPN that any rankings before the final ones are a "farce and total waste of time."

Adding to the confusion was that neither team played this weekend.

CFP selection committee chair Hunter Yurachek said Miami's 27-24 head-to-head victory against Notre Dame on Aug. 31 wasn't a deciding factor until the Hurricanes jumped BYU in the CFP rankings and were evaluated side-by-side with the Irish. Yurachek also said he encouraged committee members on Saturday night to review the Notre Dame-Miami game from Labor Day weekend.

"Once we moved Miami ahead of BYU, then we had that side-by-side comparison that everyone had been waiting for," Yurachek said. "You look at those two teams on paper, and they are almost equal in schedule strength, common opponents, and results against those opponents. But the one metric we had to fall back on, again, was the head-to-head."

Notre Dame and Miami finished with identical 10-2 records and had similar results against common opponents.

As part of a memorandum of understanding signed last year that guarantees the field will have at least 12 teams starting in 2026 and beyond, Notre Dame would be guaranteed a spot if it finishes in the top 12 next year.

By not making it this year, Notre Dame missed out on a $4 million payday for just making the field. All 12 schools in the CFP receive that amount, but the difference is that the Fighting Irish, as an independent, don't have to split it with conference members.

And that’s the real issue, at least in the eyes of the viewing public.

The greed of the Irish finally caught up with them and bit them in the ass.


ON TODAY'S SCORECARD
That Was Then

MLC

On the heels of Indiana’s stirring upset win over Ohio State in the Big Ten title game, the Hoosiers closed like Carry Back and won finished at the top team in the final College Football Playoff rankings.

Unlike Satchel Paige who so famously stated, “Don’t look back. Something might be gaining on you,”

These were the initial 12 teams ranked in the Top 12 of the CFP on Nov 4 this season, and their win-loss record at the time..

  1. Ohio State 8-0

  2. Indiana 9-0

  3. Texas A&M 8-0

  4. Alabama 7-1

  5. Georgia 7-1

  6. Ole Miss 8-1

  7. BYU 8-0

  8. Texas Tech 8-1

  9. Oregon 7-1

  1. Notre Dame 6-2

  2. Texas 7-2

  3. Oklahoma 7-2

Other teams on the cusp ranked in the initial CFP poll were: 13. Utah (7-2), 14. Virginia (8-1), 15. Louisville (7-1), 16. Vanderbilt (7-2), 17. Georgia Tech (8-1), 18. Miami Fla 6-2, 19. USC (6-2), 20. Iowa (6-2), 21. Michigan (7-2), 22. MIssouri (6-2) 23. Washington (6-2), 24. Pittsburgh (7-2), 25. Arizona (7-2).

The conclusion of the Top 12 teams in the CFP rankings include:

  1. Indiana: 13-0

  2. Ohio State: 12-1

  3. Georgia: 12-1

  4. Texas Tech: 12-1

  5. Oregon: 11-1

  6. Ole Miss: 11-1

  7. Texas A&M: 11-1

  8. Oklahoma: 10-2

  9. Alabama: 10-3

  10. Miami (Fla.): 10-2

  11. Notre Dame: 10-2

  12. BYU: 11-2

The top four teams all draw Byes.

So why are there two Group of 5 teams joining the Playoff?

Here’s the short, clean answer:

Because the 12-team College Football Playoff format uses a “5+7” model — and this year only five FBS conferences qualify as “major” leagues with guaranteed access.

Group 1: The 5 Conference Champions (Automatic Bids)

  • Big Ten champ

  • SEC champ

  • ACC champ

  • Big 12 champ

  • Highest-ranked G5 champ

Group 2: The Next 5 of the 7 At-Large Seeds

Often shown together because they must come from the at-large pool and are ranked separately from the auto-bids.

In shorthand graphics, this appears as:

  • Top 5 seeds = Conference champs

  • Next 5 seeds = At-large selections

  • Final 2 seeds = At-large but required to travel (11 vs 6 and 12 vs 5)

Bottom Line.

So hence, technically, there aren’t “two Groups of 5 teams” in the actual bracket — it’s just a visual sorting method that reflects the 5+7 structure of the new CFP system.

If this all sound confusing to you, join the club.

In the meantime, study up. There will be a quiz at the water cooler tomorrow at Noon.

TRENDING TODAY
It’s Over

MLC

One of the NBA greatest streaks came to an end last Thursday when LeBron James's 1,297-game streak of scoring 10+ points ended. He scored 8 points in a 123-120 win over Toronto.

The final play: Tie game. LeBron has the ball. Sitting on 8 points. Charges the lane... and passes out to Rui Hachimura for the game-winning three.

The narrative: What a selfless play. He didn't care about the record.

The reality

• He went 4-for-17

• His previous season low (10 points) came on 4-for-16 and 5-for-16 shooting

• He jacked up shots all game chasing the number

• If the game goes to overtime and LeBron gets his 10 points anyway

He can't lose. If he takes the shot and misses, he's selfish. If he passes and another player makes it, he's unselfish and "didn't care about the record". If he passes and Rui misses, he gets another chance in OT.

PR genius: Top 10 player of all time. Nobody manages their legacy any better.


GRINDING OUT THE PROFITS
UNDER Thunder

From Victor King’s Total Tipsheet:

The Eagles are –

1-6 UNDER on Mondays
1-6 UNDER after facing the Bears
1-5 UNDER off a home favorite loss

The Chargers are –

0-6 UNDER before the Chiefs
1-7 UNDER on Mondays


QUOTE OF THE DAY

"You change your life
by changing your heart.”

- Max Lacado


STAT OF THE DAY
1967

Indiana’s win over Ohio State on Saturday was its first conference title since 1967.

BETCHA DIDN’T KNOW
Treasure Buried in Indiana

The saddest sight of the NFL season might be Daniel Jones sitting on the turf, slamming his helmet in frustration. This isn’t how one of the league’s best comeback stories was supposed to end. Jones, cut by the lowly Giants in 2024 and reborn with the Colts, went down with an Achilles injury — and his reaction said he knew the implications instantly. The Colts probably did too.

Indianapolis never recovered in Sunday’s 36-19 loss to Jacksonville, falling to 8-5 and slipping behind the 9-4 Jaguars in the AFC South. Steve Steichen wouldn’t confirm the injury was season-ending but admitted “it doesn’t look good.” ESPN later reported Jones will undergo surgery.

The impact is enormous. The Colts started 7-1, then stumbled but remained in playoff position. Now they’re down to sixth-round rookie Riley Leonard after already losing Anthony Richardson to a freak pregame orbital fracture. Jones, on a one-year deal, had earned a shot at a major extension or franchise tag. Playing through a fibula fracture only added to his reputation, but an Achilles tear this late complicates his 2026 free-agency outlook.

The Colts now turn to Leonard, who led Notre Dame to a 14-2 record and the 2024 national championship game.

One thing is certain: Riley Leonard is not Indiana Jones.




MLC

lock
lock


The Coffee Club is a presentation of PlaybookSports.com
Feel free to share this e-newsletter with friends.

Online: PlaybookSports.com • follow @MarcLawrence •  email: coffee@PlaybookSports.com • Office: 954.377.8000


lock Privacy Policy
Playbooksports.com will never share or sell your information for any reason.No Spam. No Hassle. Unsubscribe Anytime.


Playbook (R) and Marc Lawrence's Preferred Picks (R) are registered trademarks of Preferred Picks Publications Inc. Copyright (c) 2025c) Playbook(R) Enterprises Inc. Contact Support: 1-954-377-8000. All information contained herein is for amusement purposes only. Any contrary of such information is specifically prohibited.

 

Coffee In One Hand. Confidence In The Other. The Coffee Club Way.


SIGN ME UP FOR 30 DAYS OF FRESH COFFEE DELIVERED DAILY TO MY INBOX
CLICK HERE



About Us Contact Us Log In Member Center Create An Account Privacy Policy Store

Copyright © 2025 © Playbook® Enterprises Inc.   Contact Support:  1-954-377-8000  All Logos © to their respective organizations.
This website does not endorse or encourage illegal gambling.
All information contained herein is for amusement purposes only. Any contrary of such information is specifically prohibited.