
Get ready, football fans.
You know kickoff is around the corner when ESPN college football guru Bill Connelly drops his annual Returning Production Rankings.
And the Notre Dame Fighting Irish are sitting atop the heap.
The concept is simple: the more continuity and experience you bring back, the better your chances to improve. That’s been the gold standard for years. But in today’s transfer-portal era, is it still gospel?
Connelly isn’t so sure.
“It’s critically important… when you incorporate incoming players’ stats, the explosion in transfers is dragging down returning production averages significantly.”
How big is the shift? Transfers have skyrocketed 64% in just two years—from 13.9 per team to 22.8 (23.3 including service academies). That’s not evolution… that’s upheaval.
Case in point: Clemson Tigers football.
They led the nation in returning production entering 2025, fueling hype of a Death Valley revival. Instead? Injuries, stale schemes, and stalled development sent them sliding from 10-4 (No. 22 SP+) to 7-6 (No. 34).
Still, the model isn’t broken—it’s just less predictable.
Look at last season’s hits:
-
Texas Tech Red Raiders football (No. 6 RP): jumped from 54th to 3rd, won the Big 12.
-
Kennesaw State Owls football (No. 5 RP): surged from 132nd to 89th, captured Conference USA in Year 2 of FBS.
-
Vanderbilt Commodores football (No. 3 RP): posted a 10-win season, climbed from 52nd to 11th.
Bottom line: Returning production still matters—but in 2026, it’s no longer king. It’s just one piece of a much more chaotic puzzle.
RETURNING PRODUCTION PERCENTAGES
Here are the returning production percentages and rankings for the Top 10 of all 138 FBS teams for 2026:
TEAM |
RET PROD |
OFF (RK) |
DEF (RK) |
1. Notre Dame |
72% |
67% (19) |
77% (2) |
2. Maryland |
71% |
68% (17) |
74% (4) |
3. Nebraska |
69% |
69% (14) |
69% (7) |
4. Va. Tech |
69% |
71% (9) |
67% (8) |
5. S. Carolina |
68% |
76% (2) |
61% (30) |
6. Texas |
68% |
73% (4) |
63% (19) |
7. Minnesota |
68% |
71% (10) |
65% (12) |
8. Georgia |
68% |
63% (32) |
72% (5) |
9. UCLA |
67% |
73% (5) |
61% (29) |
10. Florida |
66% |
55% (66) |
77% (1) |
NOTE: Connelly will update his rankings as the season approaches. For the latest numbers, check the 2026 PLAYBOOK Football Preview Guide magazine.
Power 4 programs return an average of 58% production, compared to just 45% from the Group of 6. Translation: the gap is real—and widening. In fact, only one G6 team cracked the Top 20, with Florida Atlantic sneaking in at No. 19… by a whisker.
Digging deeper: Notre Dame, BYU, and Texas—all CFP near-misses (Nos. 11–13)—reload in 2026 with serious upside. Different paths, same destination: these are your prime bounce-back candidates.
Regression alert: Iowa State. The Cyclones took a massive hit after losing Matt Campbell to Penn State. His replacement, Jimmy Rogers (Washington State), inherits a roster gutted by transfers—23 of 55 followed Campbell out the door. That’s not a rebuild… that’s a reset.
And they’re not alone. Memphis, South Florida, and North Texas all lost head coaches and key talent to Power 4 poachers. Expect plenty of slippage across the American.
Don’t get shut out. The 2026 Playbook Football Preview Guide drops in mid-July—with limited print supply this season. Reserve your copy now and stay ahead of the curve.

|